Visit Us!

150 Third Street
Baton Rouge, LA 70801

Call Today!

(225) 408-2600

Home • Blog • 22 Best Poboy Sandwich Recipes

22 Best Poboy Sandwich Recipes

Posted: By Milfords on October 23, 2018
The Best Poboys in Baton Rouge

best poboys in baton rouge

No food captures the spirit of Louisiana quite like the poboy.

The history of this famous and beloved sandwich is debated, but one of the most popular stories claims that the Martin brothers invented the recipe in New Orleans to feed striking streetcar drivers in 1929. These sandwiches quickly caught on throughout the region, and the Louisiana poboy was born.

This Louisiana staple varies depending on the restaurant and town, but typically, a classic poboy includes toasted French bread stuffed with some type of fried meat, and the sandwich is “dressed” with tomatoes, romaine lettuce, pickles, mayonnaise and a generous spread of hot sauce for a Creole “kick.”

To help you recreate your favorite poboy, we’ve gathered some of the best poboy recipes around — keep reading to find the perfect variation for your next meal.

1. Classic

The essential poboy recipe, this sandwich combines crispy, melt-in-your-mouth shrimp drizzled with creamy remoulade sauce for some added tang. 

The beauty of this classic down-home poboy is its simplicity. Start with New Orleans-style French bread rolls and fresh jumbo shrimp, and add butter, garlic, eggs, flour and Creole seasoning for spice. The remoulade sauce combines creamy mayonnaise and horseradish with hints of garlic and pepper for a zesty finish. Add spoonfuls of pickle relish and lime for even more classic flavor.

2. Chicken

For a twist on the classic sandwich, try cooking up a chicken poboy. Balancing butter-fried chicken breast with homemade tartar sauce, this recipe is sure to impress family and guests alike.

This poboy is all about the sauce — use a blender or food processor to cream cayenne pepper, parsley, mustard, dill pickle, scallion and mayo together to create the perfect dressing for your favorite sandwich. Breadcrumbs and butter keep the chicken crispy, and crunchy lettuce and ripe tomatoes add a fresh profile to this delicious sandwich.

3. Slim

Try this variation for the days where you want the flavor of a classic poboy without all the calories. The original poboy drips with butter — to cut back on the dairy, try sautéing the shrimp instead of frying it. This hearty alternative is filled with herbs and spices, giving it a flavor-filled finish.

Topped with a heaping portion of herb buttermilk slaw, this sandwich has enough fresh flavors to satisfy even the most dedicated poboy connoisseur. To cut down on carbs even more, choose a large baguette and hollow out the inside to make a kind of bread boat. Not only does this pack the sandwich with flavor, but it also reduces caloric intake.

Follow this recipe for a healthier take on the classic poboy!

4. Seafood

You always need a little more seafood in your life. This recipe combines shrimp and tilapia for a filling poboy with a rich, savory flavor.

Let the fish and shrimp sit in milk for a few minutes to increase creaminess. For a smooth dressing, combine garlic, lemon juice and mayonnaise then spread generously. Spread each side of the bread with the sauce and top with tomato, lettuce and the hot sauce of your choice.

You could substitute almost any type of fish to vary the taste, but whatever kind you choose, you can be sure that this will be a delicious addition to your menu.

5. Cajun

cajun poboy in baton rouge

For an extra kick, try this Cajun twist on the poboy.

This recipe uses shrimp as its base, but the sauce is the real star of this sandwich. Combine paprika, mayo, mustard, relish, cayenne pepper and hot sauce for an extra-spicy dressing that takes this poboy to the next level. If needed, you can refrigerate the sauce until you’re ready to make the sandwiches, which makes this recipe great for the days when you need to plan ahead.

If you don’t have access to New Orleans French bread, you can substitute Italian or hoagie rolls for a similarly hearty sandwich.

6. Oyster

If you can get your hands on fresh oysters, this upscale oyster poboy is a guaranteed showstopper.

The key to this poboy is soaking the oysters in milk before frying them. This gives the shellfish an added creaminess and makes sure that they have a crispy shell with a soft, melt-in-your-mouth center. The spicy remoulade sauce is a rich combination of mayo, mustard, garlic, pickle juice, capers, cayenne and horseradish. Add a dash of your favorite hot sauce to the remoulade to give these sandwiches a personal and spicy touch.

7. Crab

For the crab-lovers in your life, try this mouth-watering crab poboy recipe.

People Also Liked:  Restaurants Offering Curbside Pickup in Baton Rouge

Combining mayonnaise, crab and Old Bay seasoning, this sandwich transports you to the shoreline with fresh, seaside flavors. Crisp celery adds a satisfying crunch, and a squeeze of lemon gives this poboy a distinct, refreshing and light taste. Make sure to keep the paprika in the remoulade sauce — it gives the key flavor!

8. Alligator

You might have to live in the Deep South to make this poboy. Centered around fried alligator meat, this specialty sandwich is easy to make if you have access to fresh gator.

Once you find alligator steak, the recipe resembles a classic poboy — shredded lettuce, juicy tomatoes, Cajun seasoning and plenty of mayo in the remoulade sauce. Add a teaspoon of Everglades all-purpose seasoning for a real taste of the bayou.

For a truly unique poboy experience, buy some gator next time you’re at the market — you can even use alligator sausage for a darker meat filling.

9. Crawfish

Another Southern classic, crawfish meat has a distinct flavor — similar in taste to lobster or crab, it has a slightly chewier texture than shrimp. But this freshwater crustacean has a special place in traditional Louisiana dishes, from gumbo to crawfish étoufée.

The poboy is no exception. In this crawfish poboy recipe, you fry the crustaceans in a pale ale batter to give the sandwich a robust and crisp flavor. Finish with a spicy tartar sauce for a perfect Louisiana-style poboy.

10. Veggie

If you prefer your sandwiches without meat, try this vegetable-stuffed poboy. A variety of fresh garden veggies gives this poboy a complex, flavorful taste, and it has enough variety to please even the pickiest eater.

The secret to this recipe is grilled asparagus — this gives the sandwich smoky, charred undertones, and brings out the juice in the vegetables. Add some goat cheese for a gourmet touch, or if you want a vegan alternative, substitute cashew cheese for a creamy spread.

11. Roast Beef

For a rich and savory sandwich, look no further than a roast beef poboy. The roast brings a juicy, filling center to the sandwich, and when paired with a savory gravy-like sauce, the resulting sandwich is a perfect combination of heartiness and creaminess.

To get the most out of your roast, let it simmer for about three hours after it has been seared. The meat will absorb the flavors of garlic and pepper, and to finish the poboy, layer the sandwich with fresh lettuce, tomatoes and pickles before serving.

12. Catfish

Try a catfish poboy for a taste of the river. In this recipe, the sauce has both mustard and mayo, which gives the sandwich a touch of spice. Before frying, coat the fish in a mixture of flour, bread crumbs, cornmeal, garlic and Cajun seasoning for a genuine Louisiana taste.

Once the fish has fried, stuff it into crisp French bread or hoagie rolls and topped with a spoonful of crisp coleslaw. Add some banana peppers, cherry tomato halves and a lemon wedge, and it’s ready to serve!

13. Fried Green Tomato

Fry some green tomatoes for a meatless poboy alternative. With a crunchy coating and a soft center, these delicious tomatoes will make you forget you’re biting into vegetables.

Tomatoes aren’t the only green ingredient in this poboy — layer in a few avocado slices to add a refreshing and creamy flavor to the sandwich. Add bacon, lettuce and tomatoes for a BLT-twist, and don’t forget the Creole-inspired remoulade sauce. Stuff everything into six-inch-long baguettes and your tomato sandwiches are done!

14. Tofu

For another version of a meatless poboy, substitute meat for crispy fried tofu. The light flavor of tofu absorbs hot Cajun seasonings, creating a vegetarian sandwich with all the spice and deliciousness of a classic po’boy.

For a crispy filling, use super firm tofu and press it beforehand to remove excess water. Swap out traditional mayo for a vegan mayonnaise for a dairy-free coleslaw. If you want something different than typical French bread, try this poboy with buttery pretzel rolls.

15. Spicy Pork

spicy pork poboy baton rouge

This take on the classic poboy features grilled pork patties and a creamy mayonnaise sauce filled with pickles, shallot and spoon-full of mustard.

The grilled pork is tender and juicy, and when combined with crisp lettuce, tomatoes and spicy hot sauce, the result is a stuffed sandwich bursting with flavor. This recipe won’t take too much time, either — once the grill is hot, the pork only takes about eight minutes to cook through.

16. Buffalo Shrimp

This shrimp sandwich is anything but basic. This poboy combines crispy fried shrimp with spicy buffalo sauce for a unique take on the classic poboy recipe.

People Also Liked:  Best Seafood Restaurants in Baton Rouge

For a lighter alternative to traditional mayonnaise-based sauces, try using a bleu cheese or gorgonzola dressing — it gives you the perfect amount of creaminess without the heaviness of the classic dressings. This recipe also swaps coconut oil for butter to reduce the dairy content. Tangy and tender, this poboy is sure to be a favorite.

17. Lobster

poboy sandwiches in baton rouge

Combining buttery lobster with a stunning remoulade sauce, this lobster poboy recipe is a guaranteed success.

Season fresh lobster with garlic powder and hot sauce for a layer of spice. The sauce blends a wide variety of ingredients including mustard, mayonnaise, paprika, horseradish and Worcestershire sauce to create a creamy and refreshing spread. Toast your bread, spread the sauce and finish the sandwiches with romaine lettuce and cut tomatoes.

18. BBQ Shrimp

For a poboy with the warm taste of summer barbecue, try this recipe for BBQ shrimp poboys.

In this sandwich, the filling isn’t fried — instead, the shrimp simmer until cooked in a skillet filled with butter, Worcestershire sauce, paprika, cayenne and garlic. This keeps the shrimp tender and full of flavor. For barbecue shrimp poboys, you don’t need additional sauce — just spoon the shrimp and juice onto toasted French rolls for a perfect poboy that’s simultaneously crispy and juicy.

19. Smoked Sausage

In this sandwich, delicious beer-braised smoked sausage is topped with grilled onions and a spicy mustard sauce for an authentic Cajun taste.

The beer gives both the sausage and the onions a full and robust flavor, and the mustard and mayo sauce brings the sandwich a slight kick of spice. The combination of sweet barbecue sauce and spicy mustard spread give the poboy a depth of hearty flavor. Pile onto a toasted poboy bun and pair with Cajun barbecue sauce for additional tang.

20. Cochon de Lait

Tender pork roast is at the center of this poboy recipe. Combine with a Creole mayonnaise and refreshing coleslaw, and you have a sandwich that’s a guaranteed winner.

The key to this cochon de lait poboy is to put your roast in a slow cooker for seven to eight hours before preparation. This allows the meat to soak up flavor and keeps it moist and juicy. Once the pork begins to fall apart and shreds easily, pile it onto warm bread slathered with a tangy mayo sauce and crisp coleslaw for the ideal poboy experience.

21. Poboy Sliders

For a more portable spin on a classic po’boy, try making some poboy sliders.

These small sandwiches are filled with fried shrimp and doused in a creamy remoulade sauce. Topped with fresh lettuce and tomatoes, these sliders are the perfect food to bring to a party or event. Use your favorite hot sauce in the remoulade to control the level of spice — depending on your guests, you may need to make it more or less spicy.

Once you try them, you’ll definitely add these mini-poboys to your menu rotation!

22. Avocado Shrimp

Avocados are taking over menus around the country, and for good reason — the creamy fruit adds a rich and smooth note to just about any dish.

For this sandwich, avocados are mixed with hot sauce and salt until they have a paste consistency. Spread the avocado mixture on one side of the hot roll, fill with warm sautéed shrimp and spread mayonnaise on the other side of the sandwich.

For a classic poboy with a fresh and modern twist, try an avocado shrimp poboy for your next meal.

Mouth-Watering Poboys in Downtown Baton Rouge

poboy recipes baton rouge

For a genuine Louisiana lunch, nothing beats a warm and crispy po’boy. Why settle for less than the best?

At Milford’s on Third, we combine the freshness of a New York delicatessen with the warmth of our Southern roots. Stop by and taste one of our many lunch options, ranging from hot matzo ball soup to our signature sandwiches. We offer two distinct poboys — the Hot Sausage Poboy and the Third Street.

The Hot Sausage Poboy combines juicy split green onion sausage link with the classic poboy toppings of lettuce, tomato and a mayonnaise spread. Our Third Street poboy is piled with tender roasted round and layered with provolone, pickles, mayo and gravy for a savory and rich favor.

With daily-made, mouth-watering sandwiches, we always have something new to try. Stop by Milford’s on Third for your next Baton Rouge poboy — you won’t be disappointed!

Categories: Local Food, Lunch

49 responses to “22 Best Poboy Sandwich Recipes”

  2. I do trust all the concepts you have presented to your post.
    They are really convincing and can definitely work. Nonetheless, the posts
    are very quick for beginners. May you please lengthen them
    a bit from next time? Thanks for the post.

  3. Avid Apollo CBD Gummies Review and weed users from all walks of life favor this brand.
    ’ stories, and exploring healthy methods of integrating cannabis into every day life.

    Forbes Health covers CBD and cannabis products in accordance with FTC guidelines.
    The cartridge (or dab cart) is the top part of the vape pen that is
    a chamber that contains the cannabis oil and a mouthpiece that you’ll use
    to inhale. Again, not every vape pen is the exact same,
    but most don’t require any fancy technical work. The cost of a refillable CBD vape pen is more than a disposable, but it saves you money in the long run and allows you to mix CBD and non-CBD vape e-liquids.
    However, there is another common additive in CBD vape juices and e-liquids
    – flavourings. However, you can overcome this issue
    if you purchase from a trusted brand. In situations where CBD oil is treating anxiety in Australia, it can create a
    sense of relaxation, calm, and mood swings.
    I think this is partly related to the lessened anxiety-I feel more
    frazzled and off task when my anxiety is running high.
    10 pieces, a total how long before you feel the effects of
    cbd gummies of 250 US dollars, How can you own such a property
    as a private person!

  4. Los Angeles Chicago

    888 slot casino machinescashman casino slot games spb rucasinos near monroe la vie est bellecasino fishing slot machine editionbest casino slots in las vegas hucasinos with netent slots in usa dealsbest time of day to play slots in casino clubcasino slot machine how to play robloxhow to pick a slot machine in a casino hotelcasino royale daniel craig age mgmtharrington casino free slot play blackhow many slot machines does hollywood casino have hascasino pierre sd astana kzcasino royale bond watch online updatedouble win slots casino shopcasino vacaville ca hotelscasino royale final projectgreektown casino shooting videocasino royal full movie on netflixcasino royale ottawa dress code kenyablazing 7s 5 reel casino slots free slots online hdcasino bonus slots game passcasinos in pismo beach deluxecasino digital marketing plan007 one can casino royal moderna

    [url=https://neosymmetria.com]casino royale full online free tools[/url][url=https://neosymmetria.com]casino royale indian girl top[/url][url=https://neosymmetria.com]casino royale heroine photo young girls[/url][url=https://neosymmetria.com]casino royale las vegas 2019 x64[/url][url=https://neosymmetria.com]casino azul tequila boat[/url][url=https://neosymmetria.com]casino royale i could[/url][url=https://neosymmetria.com]cashman casino free slots machines vegas games online vtb[/url][url=https://neosymmetria.com]elle king seneca casino club[/url][url=https://neosymmetria.com]best western plus casino royale wiki how[/url][url=https://neosymmetria.com]casino royale player payback golf[/url][url=https://neosymmetria.com]casinos near oceanside ca 901[/url][url=https://neosymmetria.com]casino royale online hd free pdf[/url][url=https://neosymmetria.com]easton pa casino juju[/url][url=https://neosymmetria.com]casino slots that takes paypal uk[/url][url=https://neosymmetria.com]casino royale 2006 hd 720p english subtitles online live[/url][url=https://neosymmetria.com]agen77bet situs judi terpercaya slot dan casino online mahalla[/url][url=https://neosymmetria.com]directions to meadows casino free slot machines[/url][url=https://neosymmetria.com]fundraising casino night stand[/url][url=https://neosymmetria.com]casino royale 2006 amazon mini[/url][url=https://neosymmetria.com]bus to resorts world casino queens of the stone age[/url][url=https://neosymmetria.com]casino royale bathing suit rental[/url][url=https://neosymmetria.com]casino crown toy slot machine near me[/url][url=https://neosymmetria.com]eventos en graton casino machines[/url][url=https://neosymmetria.com]casinos colorado map roblox[/url][url=https://neosymmetria.com]casino slot games for fun online gta[/url]

  5. Los Angeles Chicago

    dog friendly casino inbond wardrobe casino royale 2006how long does it take chumba casino to pay renthigh stakes online casino download kasperskycasino las vegas slots gratis 3dcasino royale full movie in hindi mp4 720pdream about casino juju betcasino royal no deposit bonus 2022 hdbig casino slot wins 2018 na77 slot casino appcasino slots online real money so bigcasino slot games offline freeall slots casino apk iosbest slot on fanduel casino free slot machinescasino royale poker scene youtube 60casino pier surf card balance formatclosest casino to broken arrow okcasino royale 2019 indircasino insurance application jsoncasino royale eva green on set home page888 casino slot tips 1x2casino mackinaw city androiddeal or no deal slot fort mcdowell casino 2022casino parkersburg wv hotelscasino adrenaline no deposit bonus 2022 free spins

    [url=https://mycarinsurance.site]casino royale 2006 stream hd 6670[/url][url=https://mycarinsurance.site]doubledown casino slots & poker promo code all[/url][url=https://mycarinsurance.site]best slots caesars online casino del sol[/url][url=https://mycarinsurance.site]best slots casino online halykbank[/url][url=https://mycarinsurance.site]casino royale filiming location the ocean club free[/url][url=https://mycarinsurance.site]casino royale 1967 movie you tube kids[/url][url=https://mycarinsurance.site]every game casino red no deposit bonus online[/url][url=https://mycarinsurance.site]casino slots pc requirements[/url][url=https://mycarinsurance.site]aston martin 007 casino royale car mechanic simulator 2021[/url][url=https://mycarinsurance.site]casino slots apps free cam[/url][url=https://mycarinsurance.site]big daddy casino goa online play[/url][url=https://mycarinsurance.site]casino near bellaire mi one plus[/url][url=https://mycarinsurance.site]caesars casino slot machine games itunes icloud[/url][url=https://mycarinsurance.site]casino royal james bond girl girl[/url][url=https://mycarinsurance.site]777 slot machine games casino for free litecoin[/url][url=https://mycarinsurance.site]are there two casino royale movies 7 to[/url][url=https://mycarinsurance.site]casino slots mobile tracker[/url][url=https://mycarinsurance.site]cheat at casino slots slot machines[/url][url=https://mycarinsurance.site]carnival glory casino[/url][url=https://mycarinsurance.site]atoka ok casino games[/url][url=https://mycarinsurance.site]casinos in california with slots map 1 12 2[/url][url=https://mycarinsurance.site]casino royale best bond film ever 2022[/url][url=https://mycarinsurance.site]assistir filme 007 casino royale online[/url][url=https://mycarinsurance.site]ace candy slots casino machines slot[/url][url=https://mycarinsurance.site]casinos on the east coast hotel[/url]

  6. That is really fascinating, You are an excessively professional blogger. I have joined your feed and sit up for in the hunt for extra of your great post. Additionally, I’ve shared your site in my social networks

  7. Hey, you used to write excellent, but the last several posts have been kinda boring… I miss your great writings. Past several posts are just a little out of track! come on!

  9. Tremendous issues here. I’m very satisfied to see your post. Thank you a lot and I’m taking a look ahead to touch you. Will you kindly drop me a mail?

  11. I do consider all of the ideas you have presented to your post.
    They’re very convincing and will certainly work.
    Still, the posts are very brief for newbies. Could you please lengthen them a little from subsequent time?
    Thank you for the post.

  21. На сайте https://taker10.xyz вы сможете сыграть в самые интересные и увлекательные игры, которые принесут огромное количество положительных впечатлений, ярких моментов, дополнительный заработок. Сыграйте в Dice, Mines или любые другие игры. Обязательно посетите раздел с популярными играми, которые выбирает огромное количество пользователей. Попытайте свою удачу на лучших слотах и сыграйте в Live игры прямо сейчас! Дополнительная возможность заработать – воспользоваться реферальной программой и получить бонус.

  33. I do not know whether it’s just me or if everyone else experiencing problems with your site.
    It looks like some of the text in your posts are running
    off the screen. Can somebody else please provide feedback and let me
    know if this is happening to them as well? This might be a problem with my internet browser because I’ve had this happen before.
    Kudos

    My blog – vpn special coupon

  36. I just couldn’t depart your web site prior
    to suggesting that I extremely enjoyed the usual info
    a person supply on your guests? Is gonna be back
    incessantly in order to investigate cross-check new posts

  46. Thank you, I have just been searching for information about this topic for a
    while and yours is the greatest I have came upon so far.
    However, what about the conclusion? Are you sure about the supply?

  47. My coder is trying to persuade me to move to .net from
    PHP. I have always disliked the idea because of the expenses.
    But he’s tryiong none the less. I’ve been using WordPress on a variety of websites for
    about a year and am worried about switching to another platform.
    I have heard very good things about blogengine.net. Is there a way I can import all my wordpress content into it?

    Any help would be really appreciated!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

CAPTCHA

*